Math Mysteries
🏴‍☠️ PiratesGrade 5Reading: grades 5-6Place valueFractions of a numberOrder of operationsMultiplicationDivision

The Case of the Lost Golden Compass

Someone has raided the treasure hold of the Sea Serpent! The Quartermaster's golden compass is gone, leaving the crew stranded without a heading. We must track down the rogue pirate before they sail away with the loot.

Suspects

Possible suspects

Cross off a row as each clue rules it out. On screen, tap a row.

21 of 21 still in play
NamePrimary Pirate SkillSecondary Pirate GearCutlass HandednessHair StyleScurvy Weakness
William Kiddcannon blastingparrot whisperingleft-handed cutlass swingscruffy red hairticklish toes
Samuel Bellamymap decipheringsail riggingright-handed cutlass swingbraided black hairseasickness
Stede Bonnetmap decipheringpegleg kickingright-handed cutlass swingbraided black hairseasickness
Jolly Rogerrigging swingingparrot whisperingleft-handed cutlass swingbraided black hairfear of ghosts
Groggy Georgerigging swinginganchor droppingright-handed cutlass swingscruffy red hairseasickness
Redbeard Rustymap decipheringsail riggingright-handed cutlass swingbandana covered gray hairseasickness
Calico Jackmap decipheringpegleg kickingleft-handed cutlass swingbandana covered gray hairticklish toes
Sadie the Goatrigging swingingpegleg kickingleft-handed cutlass swingbandana covered gray hairfear of ghosts
Cutlass Codycrow nest scoutingsail riggingright-handed cutlass swingbraided black hairseasickness
Blackbeard Edwardcrow nest scoutingcompass navigatingright-handed cutlass swingbandana covered gray hairfear of ghosts
Edward Lowmap decipheringcompass navigatingleft-handed cutlass swingscruffy red hairfear of ghosts
Mary Readcannon blastingcompass navigatingright-handed cutlass swingbraided black hairseasickness
Barnacle Billsword duelingpegleg kickingleft-handed cutlass swingbraided black hairseasickness
Bartholomew Robertsmap decipheringcompass navigatingleft-handed cutlass swingbraided black hairticklish toes
Charles Vanecrow nest scoutingpegleg kickingleft-handed cutlass swingbraided black hairfear of ghosts
Salty Sallymap decipheringparrot whisperingright-handed cutlass swingbraided black hairseasickness
One Eyed Willyrigging swinginganchor droppingright-handed cutlass swingbraided black hairticklish toes
Anne Bonnycrow nest scoutingpegleg kickingright-handed cutlass swingbandana covered gray hairticklish toes
Grace O Malleycrow nest scoutingcompass navigatingleft-handed cutlass swingbandana covered gray hairfear of ghosts
Henry Morgancrow nest scoutinganchor droppingright-handed cutlass swingbandana covered gray hairfear of ghosts
Pegleg Petecrow nest scoutingcompass navigatingright-handed cutlass swingbraided black hairseasickness
Clue 1

Place value

The ship's ledger has a mysterious number code written on the inside cover, but the digits are smeared. Use your place value knowledge to figure out the value of the hundreds digit and crack the code!

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
80
400
50
700
20
30
9000
T
80
50
10
60
50
40
200
60
T
80
400
9000
6000
50
40
9000
20
8000
30
20
90
90
20
200
90
40
3000
20
8000
8000
40
What is the value of the 8 in 56,787?T
What is the value of the 8 in 918,760?L
What is the value of the 3 in 509,738?R
What is the value of the 6 in 726,420?V
What is the value of the 1 in 40,517?D
What is the value of the 9 in 35,597?G
What is the value of the 4 in 77,242?S
What is the value of the 4 in 910,491?H
What is the value of the 7 in 906,780?P
What is the value of the 5 in 89,753?E
What is the value of the 2 in 430,205?N
What is the value of the 9 in 29,027?A
What is the value of the 6 in 28,460?O
What is the value of the 3 in 143,646?K
What is the value of the 2 in 43,428?I
0/15 letters found
Clue 2

Fractions of a number

The crew divided up a basket of tropical papayas, but the thief took more than their fair share. Work out the exact fraction of the fruit pile to find a scrap of cloth left behind!

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

R
15
7
6
10
21
10
35
32
38
19
38
37
3
21
39
35
2
2
2
39
35
2
10
22
9
3
32
38
9
32
31
9
9
38
5/8 of 24 =R
1/4 of 8 =S
4/6 of 57 =D
1/8 of 80 =H
2/8 of 148 =C
7/8 of 8 =I
1/2 of 64 =N
1/5 of 155 =W
4/8 of 70 =A
1/3 of 27 =O
1/3 of 57 =E
4/8 of 44 =F
2/4 of 6 =U
3/8 of 16 =G
1/2 of 42 =T
1/2 of 78 =L
0/16 letters found
Clue 3

Order of operations

We found a locked safe containing the suspect's diary, but opening it requires solving a complex equation in the exact correct order of operations. Solve it to unlock the diary!

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
36
15
17
9
11
55
6
17
55
11
T
36
18
17
9
75
29
17
32
29
24
19
76
11
63
T
36
15
17
19
15
11
69
69
75
54
32
75
9 × 7 - 27 =T
2 + 5 × 6 =A
10 × 8 - 26 =B
2 + 2 × 2 =U
8 × 5 - 16 =I
2 + 4 × 4 =V
9 + 2 × 5 =C
8 × 9 - 9 =N
11 × 8 - 13 =Y
1 + 6 × 9 =G
7 + 2 × 4 =H
1 + 5 × 2 =O
36 + 8 × 5 =K
7 × 11 - 8 =P
12 × 2 - 7 =E
12 × 3 - 27 =R
14 + 3 × 5 =S
0/17 letters found
Clue 4

Multiplication facts (1-12)

The ship's gunner has stacked the heavy iron cannonballs in neat, equal rows. Multiply the rows to count the total ammunition and spot the hidden clue scratched on the wall!

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

L
50
70
70
77
33
45
L
50
2
24
63
45
42
2
88
30
77
108
33
42
33
L
50
33
12
48
70
99
48
20
33
20
2
40
40
70
24
63
10 × 5 =L
10 × 7 =O
8 × 5 =M
7 × 6 =R
11 × 8 =I
11 × 9 =N
7 × 11 =S
2 × 10 =H
8 × 3 =C
2 × 6 =F
12 × 9 =W
2 × 1 =A
5 × 9 =B
3 × 11 =E
9 × 7 =K
3 × 10 =D
6 × 8 =T
0/17 letters found
Clue 5

Division facts (1-12) — the last clue

A stash of silver doubloons must be shared equally among the deckhands. Divide the coins fairly to see how many are left over, revealing the final clue!

First solve each problem. Then find each answer in the list below and cross that sentence out. One sentence will be left — that's exactly what the villain did!

Step 1 — solve these
50 ÷ 10 = ?
132 ÷ 11 = ?
18 ÷ 6 = ?
80 ÷ 8 = ?
36 ÷ 4 = ?
66 ÷ 6 = ?
6 ÷ 1 = ?
4 ÷ 1 = ?
77 ÷ 11 = ?
12 ÷ 6 = ?
9 ÷ 9 = ?
Step 2 — cross out the sentence with each answer
1.The villain stole the map to skeleton bay, then slid down the anchor rope.
2.The villain looted the captain's chest, then escaped in a rowboat.
3.The villain swiped the golden compass, then hid in the cargo hold.
4.The villain looted the captain's chest, then ran across the wooden pier.
5.The villain stole the map to skeleton bay, then escaped in a rowboat.
6.The villain pilfered the secret key, then escaped in a rowboat.
7.The villain looted the captain's chest, then swam to the rocky shore.
8.The villain stole the map to skeleton bay, then ran across the wooden pier.
9.The villain pilfered the secret key, then ran across the wooden pier.
10.The villain looted the captain's chest, then hid in the cargo hold.
11.The villain pilfered the secret key, then slid down the anchor rope.
12.The villain plundered the ruby necklace, then hid in the cargo hold.
Solve it

Name the culprit

Choose the one suspect left standing.

About this mystery

Grade level
Grade 5 math
Math topics
Place value, Fractions of a number, Order of operations, Multiplication, Division
Reading level
grades 5-6
Theme
The Case of the Lost Golden Compass — set in The Isle of Barnacles, aboard the Sea Serpent pirate ship
Format
Interactive online & printable worksheet with answer key
Solution
One unique, verified culprit among 21 suspects

More free printable math mysteries

5th grade worksheetsMultiplication worksheetsDivision worksheetsPlace value worksheetsFractions of a number worksheetsOrder of operations worksheetsAll worksheets →
The Case of the Prism Academy Heist
Grade 5
The Secret of the Emerald Monkey Temple
Grade 5
The Mystery of the Scrambled Manuscripts
Grade 5
The Great Capacity Caper
Grade 5