Math Mysteries
⚽ SoccerGrade 1Reading: grades 3-4AdditionSubtractionSkip countingPlace valueMissing addends

The Cup Cake Caper

The championship trophy has vanished right before the big final! A mysterious soccer player called the Penalty Phantom swiped it from the center circle. The Chief Referee needs your help to check the team rosters and catch the thief before kickoff!

Suspects

Possible suspects

Cross off a row as each clue rules it out. On screen, tap a row.

21 of 21 still in play
NameSignature MoveLucky CharmDominant FootHair ColorFear
MarcusBanana ShotStriped SocksLeft-FootedPitch BlackSoggy Grass
WendieSlide TackleGolden WhistleRight-FootedPitch BlackLoud Whistles
CristianoHeaderGolden WhistleRight-FootedNeon GreenRed Cards
RobertHeaderNeon ShinguardsRight-FootedNeon GreenLoud Whistles
MeganHeaderHeadbandLeft-FootedNeon GreenSoggy Grass
LukaHeaderGolden WhistleLeft-FootedPitch BlackSoggy Grass
ErlingBicycle KickHeadbandRight-FootedBright OrangeSoggy Grass
NeymarBanana ShotWrist SweatbandLeft-FootedPitch BlackLoud Whistles
KarimVolleyStriped SocksRight-FootedBright OrangeSoggy Grass
SonnyBanana ShotHeadbandRight-FootedNeon GreenRed Cards
MohamedBicycle KickWrist SweatbandLeft-FootedBright OrangeRed Cards
AlishaHeaderHeadbandLeft-FootedPitch BlackSoggy Grass
RoseSlide TackleStriped SocksRight-FootedBright OrangeRed Cards
LionelHeaderNeon ShinguardsRight-FootedPitch BlackLoud Whistles
AlexVolleyHeadbandRight-FootedBright OrangeSoggy Grass
JudeBanana ShotNeon ShinguardsLeft-FootedBright OrangeSoggy Grass
MarthaBanana ShotStriped SocksRight-FootedPitch BlackSoggy Grass
LucySlide TackleWrist SweatbandLeft-FootedBright OrangeSoggy Grass
KylianHeaderGolden WhistleLeft-FootedNeon GreenRed Cards
ChloeBicycle KickNeon ShinguardsLeft-FootedPitch BlackSoggy Grass
KevinSlide TackleWrist SweatbandLeft-FootedPitch BlackSoggy Grass
Clue 1

Addition

Coach counted the training cones. First, she found a pile of them by the bench. Then she added the cones left on the pitch. Together, they gave a clue!

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
19
4
16
T
19
4
11
16
14
2
8
16
17
10
8
T
19
13
16
20
18
20
4
16
20
2
9
20
10
2
11 + 8 =T
1 + 3 =H
5 + 9 =F
2 + 6 =O
9 + 7 =E
12 + 6 =R
1 + 1 =D
6 + 11 =S
4 + 9 =W
9 + 11 =A
3 + 6 =B
3 + 8 =I
6 + 4 =N
0/13 letters found
Clue 2

Subtraction

The ball boy had a big sack of soccer balls, but some rolled away into the goal. Subtracting the lost balls revealed a mysterious note stuck to the sack!

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
11
10
8
7
8
18
T
11
18
4
4
T
11
6
13
19
14
T
11
1
9
12
16
8
8
6
19
14
T
11
10
8
5
2
16
18 - 7 =T
9 - 7 =U
16 - 4 =S
18 - 5 =R
10 - 3 =L
13 - 5 =E
20 - 2 =F
9 - 3 =P
6 - 2 =O
6 - 5 =W
18 - 4 =N
11 - 6 =M
15 - 6 =A
17 - 7 =H
20 - 1 =I
17 - 1 =D
0/16 letters found
Clue 3

Skip counting

We counted the cleats on the shoe rack by twos. Skip counting the shoes helped us spot a weird muddy footprint leading to the locker room!

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
15
80
90
T
15
80
110
90
35
33
10
110
8
8
90
20
30
12
20
35
90
10
10
36
12
T
15
80
90
33
36
14
14
55
14
27
30
33
33
Skip-count by 5s. Fill the blank: 5, 10, ___, 20, 25T
Skip-count by 3s. Fill the blank: 3, 6, 9, 12, 15, 18, 21, 24, 27, ___, 33, 36A
Skip-count by 3s. Fill the blank: 3, 6, 9, 12, 15, 18, 21, 24, 27, 30, 33, ___, 39, 42O
Skip-count by 10s. Fill the blank: 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, 60, 70, ___, 90, 100H
Skip-count by 3s. Fill the blank: 3, 6, 9, 12, 15, 18, 21, 24, 27, 30, ___, 36, 39S
Skip-count by 3s. Fill the blank: 3, 6, 9, 12, 15, 18, 21, 24, ___, 30, 33R
Skip-count by 5s. Fill the blank: 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, ___, 40, 45F
Skip-count by 5s. Fill the blank: 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, 35, 40, 45, 50, ___, 60, 65Y
Skip-count by 2s. Fill the blank: 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, ___, 14, 16N
Skip-count by 2s. Fill the blank: 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, 14, 16, 18, ___, 22, 24D
Skip-count by 2s. Fill the blank: 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, ___, 16, 18G
Skip-count by 10s. Fill the blank: 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, 60, 70, 80, ___, 100, 110E
Skip-count by 2s. Fill the blank: 2, 4, 6, ___, 10, 12P
Skip-count by 2s. Fill the blank: 2, 4, 6, 8, ___, 12, 14L
Skip-count by 10s. Fill the blank: 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, 60, 70, 80, 90, 100, ___, 120, 130I
0/15 letters found
Clue 4

Place value

The digital scoreboard flickered, showing tens and ones instead of the score. Reading the place value unlocked a hidden camera file!

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

W
74
12
25
86
20
63
71
37
36
95
41
78
62
31
93
37
78
35
62
37
95
14
86
63
41
62
12
36
86
80
41
What number has 7 tens and 4 ones?W
What number has 8 tens and 0 ones?S
What number has 8 tens and 6 ones?O
What number has 1 ten and 4 ones?R
What number has 6 tens and 2 ones?H
What number has 3 tens and 6 ones?P
What number has 3 tens and 5 ones?K
What number has 3 tens and 7 ones?A
What number has 2 tens and 0 ones?U
What number has 6 tens and 3 ones?N
What number has 3 tens and 1 one?B
What number has 7 tens and 1 one?D
What number has 2 tens and 5 ones?F
What number has 4 tens and 1 one?T
What number has 1 ten and 2 ones?E
What number has 9 tens and 3 ones?L
What number has 9 tens and 5 ones?I
What number has 7 tens and 8 ones?C
0/18 letters found
Clue 5

Missing addends — the last clue

The team water bottles were half-empty. We knew how many we started with, and finding the missing bottles led us straight to a scrap of jersey!

First solve each problem. Then find each answer in the list below and cross that sentence out. One sentence will be left — that's exactly what the villain did!

Step 1 — solve these
7 + ___ = 10
5 + ___ = 11
1 + ___ = 5
3 + ___ = 12
2 + ___ = 13
6 + ___ = 14
2 + ___ = 4
9 + ___ = 14
6 + ___ = 16
6 + ___ = 7
4 + ___ = 16
Step 2 — cross out the sentence with each answer
1.The villain blasted a volley, then blew a golden whistle.
2.The villain did a bicycle kick, then fixed their headband.
3.The villain made a slide tackle, then wiped their face with a wrist sweatband.
4.The villain kicked a banana shot, then pulled up their striped socks.
5.The villain blasted a volley, then wiped their face with a wrist sweatband.
6.The villain scored with a header, then blew a golden whistle.
7.The villain did a bicycle kick, then adjusted their neon shinguards.
8.The villain scored with a header, then wiped their face with a wrist sweatband.
9.The villain kicked a banana shot, then adjusted their neon shinguards.
10.The villain did a bicycle kick, then wiped their face with a wrist sweatband.
11.The villain scored with a header, then adjusted their neon shinguards.
12.The villain scored with a header, then pulled up their striped socks.
Solve it

Name the culprit

Choose the one suspect left standing.

About this mystery

Grade level
Grade 1 math
Math topics
Addition, Subtraction, Skip counting, Place value, Missing addends
Reading level
grades 3-4
Theme
The Cup Cake Caper — set in The Championship Stadium
Format
Interactive online & printable worksheet with answer key
Solution
One unique, verified culprit among 21 suspects

More free printable math mysteries

1st grade worksheetsAddition worksheetsSubtraction worksheetsPlace value worksheetsSkip counting worksheetsMissing addends worksheetsAll worksheets →
The Case of the Sparkle Crown
Grade 1
The Case of the Missing Championship Ball
Grade 1
The Great Thanksgiving Caper
Grade 1
The Thanksgiving Turkey Chase
Grade 1