Math Mysteries
🏴‍☠️ Piratet,pizzaGrade 3Reading: grades 3-4AdditionSubtractionRoundingMultiplicationDivision

The Great Anchovy Heist

Ahoy! The legendary Golden Anchovy Pizza has been stolen from the Crusty Cutlass! Captain Marinara needs your help to catch the sneaky Pizza Pirate before they eat the prize.

Suspects

Possible suspects

Cross off a row as each clue rules it out. On screen, tap a row.

21 of 21 still in play
NameSignature ToppingSecret SauceSlicing HandBandana ColorSoggy Weapon
Baron BaconSalty AnchoviesWhite AlfredoRight Handed SliceJolly Roger Black BandanaTomato Juice Splash
Scurvy SausageSweet PineappleWhite AlfredoLeft Handed SliceJolly Roger Black BandanaFlying Soda Blast
Crusty PeteSmoked SausageWhite AlfredoLeft Handed SliceDeep Sea Blue BandanaMelting Cheese Net
Captain MarinaraSalty AnchoviesWhite AlfredoRight Handed SliceDeep Sea Blue BandanaTomato Juice Splash
Shiver Me ShroomsCheesy MozzarellaWhite AlfredoRight Handed SliceCrimson Red BandanaTomato Juice Splash
Sashimi SamSalty AnchoviesWhite AlfredoRight Handed SliceCrimson Red BandanaTomato Juice Splash
Yeoman YeastSweet PineappleZesty MarinaraLeft Handed SliceCrimson Red BandanaMelting Cheese Net
Cutlass CoryCheesy MozzarellaWhite AlfredoLeft Handed SliceCrimson Red BandanaMelting Cheese Net
Barnacle BasilSpicy PepperoniZesty MarinaraRight Handed SliceCrimson Red BandanaMelting Cheese Net
Jolly JalapenoCheesy MozzarellaSweet BBQ SauceLeft Handed SliceDeep Sea Blue BandanaFlying Soda Blast
Anchovy AnneSmoked SausageSweet BBQ SauceLeft Handed SliceCrimson Red BandanaTomato Juice Splash
Captain CalzoneSpicy PepperoniSweet BBQ SauceRight Handed SliceCrimson Red BandanaMelting Cheese Net
Peggy PineappleCheesy MozzarellaGarlic ButterRight Handed SliceDeep Sea Blue BandanaFlying Soda Blast
Sir ParmesanSweet PineappleHot Chili OilRight Handed SliceCrimson Red BandanaMelting Cheese Net
Pegleg PepperoniSweet PineappleWhite AlfredoRight Handed SliceCrimson Red BandanaMelting Cheese Net
Sailor SauceSweet PineappleGarlic ButterLeft Handed SliceJolly Roger Black BandanaMelting Cheese Net
Matey MozzarellaSweet PineappleSweet BBQ SauceLeft Handed SliceJolly Roger Black BandanaFlying Soda Blast
Hook MushroomSmoked SausageZesty MarinaraRight Handed SliceCrimson Red BandanaMelting Cheese Net
Salty SophiaSmoked SausageGarlic ButterLeft Handed SliceJolly Roger Black BandanaMelting Cheese Net
Ol Blue CheeseSpicy PepperoniZesty MarinaraLeft Handed SliceCrimson Red BandanaFlying Soda Blast
Long John SilversideSalty AnchoviesWhite AlfredoRight Handed SliceDeep Sea Blue BandanaMelting Cheese Net
Clue 1

Addition

To find the first clue we must count the pepperonis on the galley floor. Let us add the toppings found under the table to the toppings in the sink.

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
940
298
395
787
591
746
418
T
940
395
987
926
395
777
289
926
T
940
930
777
395
777
581
395
395
T
940
850
850
966
777
418
930
674
395
470 + 470 =T
191 + 98 =N
631 + 356 =D
232 + 514 =R
171 + 247 =A
295 + 671 =Q
297 + 294 =I
307 + 619 =O
165 + 133 =H
414 + 363 =S
260 + 414 =C
469 + 381 =B
320 + 261 =W
592 + 338 =U
333 + 454 =P
158 + 237 =E
0/16 letters found
Clue 2

Subtraction

The cook had a full crate of fresh pineapples but the thief stole some. We can find a clue if we subtract the remaining pineapples from the starting amount.

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
303
552
120
823
327
120
118
120
552
162
823
354
696
897
552
T
303
552
162
118
256
120
256
823
646
696
327
120
307
162
354
160
823
638 - 335 =T
1151 - 328 =S
998 - 302 =I
908 - 11 =G
520 - 358 =A
589 - 235 =R
142 - 22 =E
485 - 158 =C
347 - 40 =M
439 - 279 =K
835 - 283 =H
923 - 277 =L
489 - 233 =D
149 - 31 =N
0/14 letters found
Clue 3

Rounding

The ship's radar shows the thief's escape speed but the old dial only displays numbers rounded to the nearest ten. Round the speed to unlock the message.

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
3000
9000
2000
T
3000
9000
500
2000
50
5000
7000
400
70
50
5000
40
800
800
2000
90
T
3000
500
400
8000
700
9000
2000
2000
70
2000
400
2000
T
3000
Round 3,274 to the nearest thousandT
Round 47 to the nearest tenF
Round 7,004 to the nearest thousandU
Round 4,643 to the nearest thousandR
Round 457 to the nearest hundredI
Round 72 to the nearest tenS
Round 811 to the nearest hundredM
Round 9,167 to the nearest thousandH
Round 1,819 to the nearest thousandE
Round 39 to the nearest tenO
Round 389 to the nearest hundredN
Round 695 to the nearest hundredC
Round 94 to the nearest tenL
Round 7,908 to the nearest thousandG
0/14 letters found
Clue 4

Multiplication facts (1-12)

We found stacks of empty pizza boxes in the hold. If we multiply the number of stacks by the boxes in each stack we will uncover a hidden note.

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

A
50
30
70
88
36
11
2
24
70
96
108
4
A
50
24
108
A
50
24
A
50
6
10
70
96
A
50
108
99
A
50
11
45
2
32
24
108
10 × 5 =A
11 × 8 =I
5 × 6 =C
4 × 1 =B
1 × 10 =H
7 × 10 =R
9 × 11 =W
12 × 8 =E
2 × 3 =T
8 × 4 =U
1 × 2 =O
12 × 9 =D
5 × 9 =F
3 × 12 =M
8 × 3 =N
11 × 1 =S
0/16 letters found
Clue 5

Division facts (1-12) — the last clue

The pirate crew wants to share a bunch of breadsticks equally. If we divide the total breadsticks among the sailors the leftover amount tells us where to look.

First solve each problem. Then find each answer in the list below and cross that sentence out. One sentence will be left — that's exactly what the villain did!

Step 1 — solve these
54 ÷ 6 = ?
49 ÷ 7 = ?
33 ÷ 3 = ?
72 ÷ 9 = ?
3 ÷ 1 = ?
2 ÷ 2 = ?
40 ÷ 4 = ?
30 ÷ 6 = ?
24 ÷ 6 = ?
108 ÷ 9 = ?
20 ÷ 10 = ?
Step 2 — cross out the sentence with each answer
1.The villain scatters salty anchovies to distract the crew, then slides away on hot chili oil.
2.The villain flings sweet pineapple slices like mini shields, then escapes using a burst of garlic butter.
3.The villain scatters salty anchovies to distract the crew, then escapes using a burst of garlic butter.
4.The villain tosses spicy pepperoni on the deck, then blinds the guards with white alfredo.
5.The villain scatters salty anchovies to distract the crew, then sprays zesty marinara everywhere.
6.The villain flings sweet pineapple slices like mini shields, then blinds the guards with white alfredo.
7.The villain rolls smoked sausage down the gangplank, then sprays zesty marinara everywhere.
8.The villain scatters salty anchovies to distract the crew, then swings on a rope coated in sweet bbq sauce.
9.The villain flings sweet pineapple slices like mini shields, then slides away on hot chili oil.
10.The villain rolls smoked sausage down the gangplank, then blinds the guards with white alfredo.
11.The villain tosses spicy pepperoni on the deck, then sprays zesty marinara everywhere.
12.The villain tosses spicy pepperoni on the deck, then escapes using a burst of garlic butter.
Solve it

Name the culprit

Choose the one suspect left standing.

About this mystery

Grade level
Grade 3 math
Math topics
Addition, Subtraction, Rounding, Multiplication, Division
Reading level
grades 3-4
Theme
The Great Anchovy Heist — set in The Crusty Cutlass pizza ship in the Sea of Cheese
Format
Interactive online & printable worksheet with answer key
Solution
One unique, verified culprit among 21 suspects

More free printable math mysteries

3rd grade worksheetsAddition worksheetsSubtraction worksheetsMultiplication worksheetsDivision worksheetsRounding worksheetsAll worksheets →
The Great Balloon Mystery
Grade 3
The Balloon Fiesta Mystery
Grade 3
The Sandy Flats Sandbox Mystery
Grade 3
The Mystery of the Missing Beacon
Grade 3