Math Mysteries
🔎 Halloween, pumpkins, fallGrade 5Reading: grades 3-4AdditionSubtractionMultiplicationFractions of a numberDivision

The Great Pumpkin Patch Caper

The giant, prize-winning pumpkin has vanished from the patch! All that remains are some squashed vines and a chilly autumn breeze. We must track down the culprit before the spooky Halloween Festival begins tonight!

Suspects

Possible suspects

Cross off a row as each clue rules it out. On screen, tap a row.

21 of 21 still in play
NameTrick PowerFall GearCarving StyleAutumn HeadwearSecret Obstacle
Barnaby BaleSpooky Shadow WarpCorn Husk CapeCarries a left handed carving knifeBlack pointed hoodAllergic to cinnamon
Autumn AveryCrows CallHay Bale ArmorCarries a left handed carving knifeBlack pointed hoodStops to eat pumpkin pie
Molly MoonSpooky Shadow WarpHaunted LanternCarries a left handed carving knifeOrange stem hatAllergic to cinnamon
Paula PipsqueakPumpkin BlastHay Bale ArmorCarries a left handed carving knifeOrange stem hatStops to eat pumpkin pie
Tammy TreatPumpkin BlastHaunted LanternCarries a right handed carving knifeGreen leaf beanieStops to eat pumpkin pie
Oliver OwlCrows CallWitch BroomCarries a right handed carving knifeOrange stem hatAllergic to cinnamon
Sammy SquashCrows CallCorn Husk CapeCarries a left handed carving knifeOrange stem hatStops to eat pumpkin pie
Sally ScarecrowSpooky Shadow WarpHaunted LanternCarries a left handed carving knifeBlack pointed hoodAllergic to cinnamon
Peter PatchWind GustCandied Apple ShieldCarries a left handed carving knifeOrange stem hatAllergic to cinnamon
Wendy WitchWind GustHaunted LanternCarries a right handed carving knifeOrange stem hatAllergic to cinnamon
Charlie CiderPumpkin BlastCandied Apple ShieldCarries a left handed carving knifeOrange stem hatAllergic to cinnamon
Jack LanternSpooky Shadow WarpCorn Husk CapeCarries a left handed carving knifeOrange stem hatAllergic to cinnamon
Ghostly GabeSpooky Shadow WarpHaunted LanternCarries a left handed carving knifeGreen leaf beanieScared of scarecrows
Hunter HarvestWind GustWitch BroomCarries a left handed carving knifeGreen leaf beanieStops to eat pumpkin pie
Billy BooPumpkin BlastHaunted LanternCarries a right handed carving knifeOrange stem hatScared of scarecrows
Cora CornPumpkin BlastCandied Apple ShieldCarries a right handed carving knifeGreen leaf beanieScared of scarecrows
Hazel NutVine GrabHay Bale ArmorCarries a left handed carving knifeGreen leaf beanieScared of scarecrows
Bobby BatPumpkin BlastHaunted LanternCarries a left handed carving knifeOrange stem hatAllergic to cinnamon
Pippa PumpkinWind GustCorn Husk CapeCarries a right handed carving knifeGreen leaf beanieStops to eat pumpkin pie
Rusty MapleSpooky Shadow WarpWitch BroomCarries a right handed carving knifeGreen leaf beanieAllergic to cinnamon
Penny PieWind GustCandied Apple ShieldCarries a right handed carving knifeGreen leaf beanieAllergic to cinnamon
Clue 1

Addition

To track the bandit, we tallied the squashed pumpkins in each row of the patch. Adding up the broken gourds revealed a clue.

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
2840
8607
4884
T
2840
8607
4859
4884
4694
7200
9042
4884
2148
8041
9042
T
2840
6522
4884
7734
5567
7734
4846
9042
5567
8041
8607
6504
2148
9336
4846
7734
9672
4884
1208 + 1632 =T
3632 + 4409 =N
3796 + 4811 =H
4078 + 5258 =K
2516 + 4006 =W
4659 + 4383 =O
6116 + 3556 =P
2552 + 3015 =R
1469 + 3377 =C
4212 + 2292 =U
4402 + 2798 =D
2341 + 2353 =F
2663 + 2221 =E
1075 + 1073 =S
4881 + 2853 =A
1842 + 3017 =I
0/16 letters found
Clue 2

Subtraction

The thief snatched some apples from the basket. We subtracted the remaining apples from the starting total to find how many they took.

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
3380
7789
8947
8198
2464
8198
4748
8947
1613
T
3380
1613
8687
2207
4258
8947
8198
5739
6579
T
3380
7789
T
3380
7789
8947
6579
2207
6310
8947
6209
T
3380
7789
8687
5180
5149
7990 - 4610 =T
8483 - 3735 =P
11312 - 3523 =H
8797 - 3058 =W
11107 - 2420 =A
7884 - 2735 =D
9641 - 3331 =L
12577 - 4379 =S
4425 - 167 =V
4633 - 3020 =C
7034 - 4570 =U
10111 - 1164 =E
6261 - 1081 =N
8089 - 1510 =I
3263 - 1056 =R
10638 - 4429 =F
0/16 letters found
Clue 3

Multiplication facts (1-12)

We counted the rows of corn mazes. Multiplying the rows by the number of stalks in each row led us to a dropped clue.

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
63
15
14
84
60
14
14
144
100
60
30
64
100
10
10
88
100
60
15
88
T
63
14
84
16
100
60
60
88
21
35
60
9 × 7 =T
5 × 12 =N
2 × 7 =E
10 × 10 =I
7 × 5 =O
7 × 3 =M
5 × 3 =H
12 × 7 =S
2 × 5 =L
8 × 11 =A
12 × 12 =Z
8 × 8 =V
8 × 2 =C
6 × 5 =G
0/14 letters found
Clue 4

Fractions of a number

The bandit dropped some candy corn. We calculated exactly half of the dropped pile to figure out where they headed next.

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

W
40
27
18
17
32
30
21
9
30
17
39
9
30
8
27
7
5
27
10
37
9
5
9
5
5
37
27
26
9
5
2
37
2/3 of 60 =W
1/2 of 10 =T
3/4 of 52 =R
5/10 of 16 =G
5/10 of 64 =U
1/10 of 70 =S
2/4 of 60 =N
5/10 of 18 =A
3/6 of 36 =F
3/6 of 20 =M
1/2 of 74 =H
1/10 of 170 =O
4/10 of 65 =P
3/6 of 42 =D
1/4 of 108 =E
1/3 of 6 =C
0/16 letters found
Clue 5

Division facts (1-12) — the last clue

We shared the remaining pie slices equally among our team. Dividing the slices gave us the final hint we needed.

First solve each problem. Then find each answer in the list below and cross that sentence out. One sentence will be left — that's exactly what the villain did!

Step 1 — solve these
18 ÷ 3 = ?
14 ÷ 2 = ?
27 ÷ 3 = ?
30 ÷ 6 = ?
100 ÷ 10 = ?
40 ÷ 10 = ?
44 ÷ 4 = ?
108 ÷ 9 = ?
80 ÷ 10 = ?
18 ÷ 9 = ?
36 ÷ 12 = ?
Step 2 — cross out the sentence with each answer
1.The villain scared away the farm crows, then stole a warm mug of apple cider.
2.The villain smashed three small gourds, then left a trail of candy wrappers.
3.The villain smashed three small gourds, then howled like a graveyard wolf.
4.The villain smashed three small gourds, then dropped a bunch of dry leaves.
5.The villain rolled pumpkins down the hill, then dropped a bunch of dry leaves.
6.The villain smashed three small gourds, then splattered pumpkin seeds everywhere.
7.The villain carved a giant spooky face, then splattered pumpkin seeds everywhere.
8.The villain tangled up the grapevines, then left a trail of candy wrappers.
9.The villain smashed three small gourds, then stole a warm mug of apple cider.
10.The villain carved a giant spooky face, then left a trail of candy wrappers.
11.The villain scared away the farm crows, then left a trail of candy wrappers.
12.The villain carved a giant spooky face, then dropped a bunch of dry leaves.
Solve it

Name the culprit

Choose the one suspect left standing.

About this mystery

Grade level
Grade 5 math
Math topics
Addition, Subtraction, Multiplication, Fractions of a number, Division
Reading level
grades 3-4
Theme
The Great Pumpkin Patch Caper — set in Spooky Hollow Pumpkin Patch
Format
Interactive online & printable worksheet with answer key
Solution
One unique, verified culprit among 21 suspects

More free printable math mysteries

5th grade worksheetsAddition worksheetsSubtraction worksheetsMultiplication worksheetsDivision worksheetsFractions of a number worksheetsAll worksheets →
The Mystery of the Captain's Compass
Grade 5
The Case of the Missing Golden Anchovy
Grade 5
The Great Pumpkin Patch Mystery
Grade 5
The Water Tower Capers
Grade 5