Math Mysteries
🏴‍☠️ PiratesGrade 2Reading: grades 1-2Place valueAdditionSubtractionWord problemsMissing addends

The Mystery of the Lost Pirate Treasure

Oh no! A sneaky pirate thief has taken the golden key to the main treasure chest! Captain Barnaby needs your help. Look for clues around the pirate ship to catch the thief.

Suspects

Possible suspects

Cross off a row as each clue rules it out. On screen, tap a row.

21 of 21 still in play
NamePirate SkillMagic GearHook HandHead GearBig Fear
Captain Kiddcannon blasterghost lanternright handed hooktricorn hathates loud music
Grace OMalleymap decodersea shell radioleft handed hookcaptain wigtickled by feathers
Jolly Rogercannon blastermagic compassleft handed hooktricorn hattickled by feathers
Pirate Petespyglass eyemagic compassright handed hookcaptain wigtickled by feathers
Captain Barnabymap decodermagic compassleft handed hookbandana wrapscared of frogs
Calico Jackhook handpeg leg boosterright handed hookcaptain wigscared of frogs
Anchor Andyparrot whisperermagic compassright handed hooktricorn hatscared of frogs
Scurvy Stevecannon blastersea shell radioleft handed hookcaptain wighates loud music
Sailor Sallyhook handpeg leg boosterright handed hookcaptain wigtickled by feathers
LArionoisehook handwind sailleft handed hookbandana wraptickled by feathers
Pegleg Paulmap decoderpeg leg boosterright handed hookbandana wrapscared of frogs
Helmsman Hankmap decoderwind sailright handed hooktricorn hattickled by feathers
Anne Bonnycannon blasterwind sailleft handed hooktricorn hathates loud music
Blackbeardspyglass eyepeg leg boosterright handed hooktricorn hatscared of frogs
Stede Bonnetspyglass eyewind sailright handed hookcaptain wigtickled by feathers
Henry Morgancannon blasterghost lanternright handed hookbandana wraphates loud music
Cannonball Katespyglass eyesea shell radioright handed hooktricorn hathates loud music
Sailor Suemap decoderwind sailright handed hookcaptain wigtickled by feathers
Cutlass Claraspyglass eyepeg leg boosterright handed hooktricorn hattickled by feathers
Captain Pattyspyglass eyemagic compassleft handed hookbandana wraphates loud music
Barnacle Billhook handsea shell radioright handed hookcaptain wigtickled by feathers
Clue 1

Place value

We found a dusty lockbox with a code. To open it, we need to look at the tens and ones places on the gold scale. Let us find the digit values!

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
97
19
94
20
98
70
66
T
97
94
48
58
94
90
65
58
T
97
19
66
68
94
66
40
66
84
98
82
82
58
40
20
66
90
90
What number has 9 tens and 7 ones?T
What number has 4 tens and 0 ones?M
What number has 6 tens and 8 ones?V
What number has 2 tens and 0 ones?P
What number has 9 tens and 4 ones?E
What number has 9 tens and 8 ones?I
What number has 8 tens and 2 ones?C
What number has 9 tens and 0 ones?S
What number has 6 tens and 5 ones?N
What number has 7 tens and 0 ones?R
What number has 4 tens and 8 ones?D
What number has 1 ten and 9 ones?H
What number has 6 tens and 6 ones?A
What number has 8 tens and 4 ones?G
What number has 5 tens and 8 ones?O
0/15 letters found
Clue 2

Addition

Barnaby counted the pirate hats on the deck. He added more hats from the cabin. Let us add the numbers to see how many we have in total!

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
32
57
81
67
78
79
81
84
57
53
40
84
95
46
26
96
57
T
32
57
95
85
73
81
73
57
53
53
39
10 + 22 =T
11 + 28 =K
21 + 19 =W
17 + 40 =H
24 + 43 =C
42 + 39 =E
68 + 28 =G
40 + 44 =S
22 + 24 =R
31 + 42 =D
30 + 48 =L
19 + 7 =I
42 + 43 =N
58 + 37 =A
44 + 35 =U
30 + 23 =O
0/16 letters found
Clue 3

Subtraction

A heavy wave hit the ship and some water barrels fell into the sea. Let us subtract the lost barrels from our ship supply to find what is left!

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
53
52
73
45
24
36
36
29
24
74
70
29
14
T
53
24
27
40
36
73
69
82
18
38
73
29
T
53
52
73
12
14
56 - 3 =T
25 - 1 =I
75 - 6 =D
47 - 18 =A
33 - 21 =R
105 - 23 =B
56 - 16 =K
71 - 19 =H
16 - 2 =S
57 - 39 =Y
71 - 26 =V
89 - 15 =N
86 - 13 =E
50 - 23 =C
110 - 40 =W
78 - 40 =F
64 - 28 =L
0/17 letters found
Clue 4

Word problems

The ship chef wants to share the sour lime treats. We must solve a quick word puzzle to know how many limes each young pirate gets.

Solve each problem to learn its letter, then write the letters in the boxes to fill in the missing word.

Astrandof
C
24
37
32
27
37
33
7
40
33
G
 
hairturnedupatthescene.
Captain Barnaby lined up 6 rows of 4 gold coins. How many gold coins in all?C
There were 17 wooden planks. 10 were used up. How many wooden planks are left?N
Captain Barnaby lined up 4 rows of 8 sour limes. How many sour limes in all?P
Captain Barnaby found 9 coconut cups yesterday and 18 more today. How many coconut cups in all?T
Captain Barnaby lined up 8 rows of 5 coconut cups. How many coconut cups in all?W
There were 36 shiny shells. 3 were used up. How many shiny shells are left?I
There were 46 sour limes. 9 were used up. How many sour limes are left?A
0/7 letters found
Clue 5

Missing addends — the last clue

The captain needs twelve cannonballs, but some are missing from the rack. Let us find the missing number to make a full set for the battle!

First solve each problem. Then find each answer in the list below and cross that sentence out. One sentence will be left — that's exactly what the villain did!

Step 1 — solve these
10 + ___ = 17
5 + ___ = 11
7 + ___ = 9
2 + ___ = 10
8 + ___ = 19
3 + ___ = 12
1 + ___ = 4
7 + ___ = 8
9 + ___ = 19
3 + ___ = 7
7 + ___ = 19
Step 2 — cross out the sentence with each answer
1.The villain took the secret pirate map, then escaped in a tiny rowboat.
2.The villain took the secret pirate map, then jumped onto the big ship.
3.The villain hid the captain wooden leg, then ran down the dock.
4.The villain stole the shiny treasure chest, then jumped onto the big ship.
5.The villain stole the shiny treasure chest, then fled into the dark cave.
6.The villain grabbed the golden skull key, then jumped onto the big ship.
7.The villain stole the shiny treasure chest, then escaped in a tiny rowboat.
8.The villain grabbed the golden skull key, then escaped in a tiny rowboat.
9.The villain stole the shiny treasure chest, then ran down the dock.
10.The villain took the talking parrot, then escaped in a tiny rowboat.
11.The villain stole the shiny treasure chest, then swam out to the island.
12.The villain took the secret pirate map, then fled into the dark cave.
Solve it

Name the culprit

Choose the one suspect left standing.

About this mystery

Grade level
Grade 2 math
Math topics
Place value, Addition, Subtraction, Word problems, Missing addends
Reading level
grades 1-2
Theme
The Mystery of the Lost Pirate Treasure — set in Scurvy Cove
Format
Interactive online & printable worksheet with answer key
Solution
One unique, verified culprit among 21 suspects

More free printable math mysteries

2nd grade worksheetsAddition worksheetsSubtraction worksheetsPlace value worksheetsMissing addends worksheets🏴‍☠️ Pirates worksheetsAll worksheets →
The Case of the Cosmic Cat Cruiser
Grade 2
The Rustreef Reef Mystery
Grade 2
The Cosmic Canopy Caper
Grade 2
The Pearl of Coral Cove
Grade 2