Math Mysteries
🔎 SoftballGrade 4Reading: grades 3-4AdditionRoundingSubtractionMultiplicationDivision

The Mystery of the Missing Golden Softball

The biggest game of the year is about to start, but someone has stolen the Golden Championship Softball! The umpire found muddy footprints leading away from the trophy case. We need to solve the math puzzles, gather clues, and find out which player took the golden ball before the final inning!

Suspects

Possible suspects

Cross off a row as each clue rules it out. On screen, tap a row.

21 of 21 still in play
NameBest SkillSpecial GearBatting StanceHair StyleField Obstacle
Maya BradyOutfield gliderSuper grip pine tarLeft handed batting stanceCurly bubble ponytailBright stadium lights
Piper PresleyBase stealerSuper grip pine tarLeft handed batting stanceHigh braided ponytailBright stadium lights
Haylie McCleneyPower hitterWeighted batting glovesRight handed batting stanceHigh braided ponytailBright stadium lights
Chloe CoyleOutfield gliderGolden cleat spikesLeft handed batting stanceHigh braided ponytailLoud air horns
Valerie CagleBase stealerGlow in the dark batLeft handed batting stanceCurly bubble ponytailLoud air horns
Aliyah AndrewsBunt masterSuper grip pine tarLeft handed batting stanceCurly bubble ponytailLoud air horns
Jayda ColemanFastpitch fireballerSuper grip pine tarLeft handed batting stanceSlicked back visor bunSoggy infield clay
Jennie FinchBase stealerWeighted batting glovesLeft handed batting stanceCurly bubble ponytailLoud air horns
Jocelyn AloBase stealerGlow in the dark batLeft handed batting stanceHigh braided ponytailLoud air horns
Rachel GarciaBase stealerHigh tech radar visorRight handed batting stanceSlicked back visor bunBright stadium lights
Cat OstermanFastpitch fireballerSuper grip pine tarLeft handed batting stanceSlicked back visor bunBright stadium lights
Bailey BuntBase stealerWeighted batting glovesRight handed batting stanceCurly bubble ponytailLoud air horns
Tiare JenningsPower hitterSuper grip pine tarRight handed batting stanceSlicked back visor bunLoud air horns
NiJaree CanadyPower hitterGlow in the dark batRight handed batting stanceSlicked back visor bunLoud air horns
Sierra RomeroPower hitterGolden cleat spikesLeft handed batting stanceCurly bubble ponytailLoud air horns
Sis BatesBase stealerHigh tech radar visorLeft handed batting stanceCurly bubble ponytailLoud air horns
Montana FoutsBunt masterHigh tech radar visorLeft handed batting stanceSlicked back visor bunSoggy infield clay
Kelly BarnhillOutfield gliderSuper grip pine tarRight handed batting stanceCurly bubble ponytailSoggy infield clay
Keilani RickettsFastpitch fireballerWeighted batting glovesRight handed batting stanceCurly bubble ponytailLoud air horns
Kinzie HansenBase stealerWeighted batting glovesLeft handed batting stanceSlicked back visor bunBright stadium lights
Skylar WallaceBunt masterGolden cleat spikesRight handed batting stanceCurly bubble ponytailLoud air horns
Clue 1

Addition

To find the first clue we need to count the softballs in the dugout. Help the coach tally the buckets of yellow balls.

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
6068
3170
5656
T
6068
3170
9419
5656
6590
6142
3485
5656
5992
7970
3485
T
6068
9324
5656
8058
4528
8058
4528
8058
6142
8058
4528
4314
9419
5992
3485
4528
3177 + 2891 =T
6143 + 3276 =I
5058 + 4266 =W
3790 + 4180 =N
1979 + 2335 =V
4741 + 3317 =A
2507 + 3149 =E
1961 + 4031 =S
1529 + 2999 =R
2318 + 4272 =F
2688 + 3454 =D
1464 + 2021 =O
1407 + 1763 =H
0/13 letters found
Clue 2

Rounding

The radar gun caught a fast throw but the digital screen is cracked. Round the speed to the nearest ten to clear the screen.

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

L
170
70
20
230
3700
20
5000
5000
230
110
50
700
4300
230
3000
90
70
50
70
L
170
70
20
230
700
4300
230
130
70
1100
5000
290
Round 167 to the nearest tenL
Round 133 to the nearest tenH
Round 5,120 to the nearest thousandO
Round 74 to the nearest tenE
Round 290 to the nearest tenX
Round 86 to the nearest tenW
Round 3,669 to the nearest hundredY
Round 4,326 to the nearest hundredN
Round 690 to the nearest hundredI
Round 54 to the nearest tenR
Round 228 to the nearest tenT
Round 1,089 to the nearest hundredB
Round 16 to the nearest tenF
Round 111 to the nearest tenP
Round 3,035 to the nearest thousandS
0/15 letters found
Clue 3

Subtraction

The team lost some batting helmets when the gear bag spilled. Subtract the missing gear to see what is left.

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
6544
5810
6263
8374
8424
8374
4108
6263
1242
T
6544
8374
5810
6319
5625
5066
2981
5625
3013
5625
1737
5831
6319
7947
3440
7873
7947
8424
5758
5810
7947
6319
5066
8374
7305 - 761 =T
8856 - 3025 =F
7219 - 3111 =P
9385 - 961 =U
8250 - 377 =L
11113 - 3166 =O
8435 - 2116 =R
10048 - 1674 =S
5781 - 4539 =C
7254 - 4241 =W
9601 - 3791 =H
4842 - 3105 =Y
6989 - 4008 =K
7407 - 3967 =M
8195 - 1932 =E
6344 - 586 =D
6001 - 935 =N
7804 - 2179 =A
0/18 letters found
Clue 4

Multiplication facts (1-12)

The grandstands are packed with cheering fans. Multiply the number of rows by the seats in each row to find the total.

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

W
99
42
7
56
60
120
3
28
54
60
120
44
121
6
25
110
70
27
110
42
28
7
56
70
25
30
60
30
30
14
42
9 × 11 =W
11 × 11 =Y
2 × 7 =L
4 × 7 =S
3 × 10 =B
9 × 6 =P
4 × 11 =K
12 × 5 =U
10 × 12 =N
6 × 7 =E
3 × 9 =T
7 × 8 =O
1 × 7 =F
11 × 10 =I
2 × 3 =H
10 × 7 =R
1 × 3 =D
5 × 5 =A
0/18 letters found
Clue 5

Division facts (1-12) — the last clue

The umpire wants to share orange slices evenly with the outfielders. Divide the slices to get the final clue.

First solve each problem. Then find each answer in the list below and cross that sentence out. One sentence will be left — that's exactly what the villain did!

Step 1 — solve these
77 ÷ 11 = ?
28 ÷ 7 = ?
70 ÷ 7 = ?
12 ÷ 2 = ?
16 ÷ 8 = ?
6 ÷ 2 = ?
99 ÷ 11 = ?
12 ÷ 1 = ?
20 ÷ 4 = ?
6 ÷ 6 = ?
40 ÷ 5 = ?
Step 2 — cross out the sentence with each answer
1.The villain slid safely into third base, then wiped pine tar on the bench.
2.The villain threw a blinding fastpitch softball, then dropped heavy batting gloves.
3.The villain slid safely into third base, then checked their high tech radar visor.
4.The villain slid safely into third base, then dropped heavy batting gloves.
5.The villain slid safely into third base, then left shiny cleat marks in the dirt.
6.The villain hit a massive home run ball, then swung a glowing bat to escape.
7.The villain executed a sneaky drag bunt, then wiped pine tar on the bench.
8.The villain threw a blinding fastpitch softball, then checked their high tech radar visor.
9.The villain executed a sneaky drag bunt, then dropped heavy batting gloves.
10.The villain hit a massive home run ball, then left shiny cleat marks in the dirt.
11.The villain slid safely into third base, then swung a glowing bat to escape.
12.The villain made a diving catch in center field, then left shiny cleat marks in the dirt.
Solve it

Name the culprit

Choose the one suspect left standing.

About this mystery

Grade level
Grade 4 math
Math topics
Addition, Rounding, Subtraction, Multiplication, Division
Reading level
grades 3-4
Theme
The Mystery of the Missing Golden Softball — set in the Sunnyvale Softball Complex
Format
Interactive online & printable worksheet with answer key
Solution
One unique, verified culprit among 21 suspects

More free printable math mysteries

4th grade worksheetsAddition worksheetsSubtraction worksheetsMultiplication worksheetsDivision worksheetsRounding worksheetsAll worksheets →
The Great Softball Heist
Grade 4
The Imperial Map Mystery
Grade 4
The Treehouse Raider
Grade 4
The Dark Wizard Hunt
Grade 4