Math Mysteries
🔎 Pizza delivery peopleGrade 3Reading: grades 3-4SubtractionAdditionMultiplicationRoundingDivision

The Case of the Golden Anchovy

Oh no! The legendary Golden Anchovy trophy has been stolen right out of the display case at Cheesy Valley Headquarters! The thief left a messy trail of flour and empty delivery boxes. It must be one of our own delivery drivers! Use your math skills to help us crack the clues and catch the culprit before they deliver the trophy to a rival pizzeria!

Suspects

Possible suspects

Cross off a row as each clue rules it out. On screen, tap a row.

21 of 21 still in play
NameDelivery RidePizza BonusSignature HandHair StyleDelivery Fear
Saucy SallyRocket SkateboardSpicy PeppersLeft handed deliveryCurly HairDeep Potholes
Anita AnchovyTurbo ScooterFizzy SodaLeft handed deliveryCurly HairDeep Potholes
Scooter ScottRocket SkateboardGarlic KnotsLeft handed deliveryStraight HairStuck Elevators
Calzone CarlSleek Go-KartCheesy BreadLeft handed deliveryCurly HairDeep Potholes
Olivia OliveSpeedy BicycleFizzy SodaRight handed deliverySpiky HairStuck Elevators
Garlic GarySpeedy BicycleFizzy SodaRight handed deliveryCurly HairBarking Dogs
Pepperoni PeteRocket SkateboardGarlic KnotsRight handed deliveryCurly HairDeep Potholes
Vinnie VeggieClassic Delivery VanCheesy BreadRight handed deliverySpiky HairBarking Dogs
Mamma MargheritaTurbo ScooterFizzy SodaRight handed deliveryStraight HairBarking Dogs
Patsy PestoTurbo ScooterCinnamon SticksLeft handed deliveryCurly HairStuck Elevators
Bella BasilClassic Delivery VanCheesy BreadLeft handed deliveryCurly HairDeep Potholes
Penny PineappleClassic Delivery VanCinnamon SticksRight handed deliverySpiky HairBarking Dogs
Freddy FreebieRocket SkateboardCinnamon SticksLeft handed deliveryCurly HairDeep Potholes
Tony TomatoSpeedy BicycleCinnamon SticksLeft handed deliverySpiky HairDeep Potholes
Ancho AndySpeedy BicycleSpicy PeppersRight handed deliverySpiky HairStuck Elevators
Mozzarella MiaClassic Delivery VanGarlic KnotsLeft handed deliveryCurly HairStuck Elevators
Gino GiovanniSpeedy BicycleCinnamon SticksRight handed deliveryCurly HairDeep Potholes
Paolo ParmesanClassic Delivery VanGarlic KnotsLeft handed deliverySpiky HairBarking Dogs
Slice SamSpeedy BicycleFizzy SodaLeft handed deliverySpiky HairStuck Elevators
Crusty ChrisSpeedy BicycleFizzy SodaRight handed deliveryCurly HairDeep Potholes
Dina DeliverySleek Go-KartCinnamon SticksLeft handed deliveryCurly HairBarking Dogs
Clue 1

Subtraction

Chef Luigi counts the pizza boxes left in the warming oven. Some are missing! We can subtract the remaining boxes from the morning total to find our first clue.

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
742
360
281
T
742
360
818
281
166
196
818
196
738
534
T
742
263
408
375
375
730
513
798
818
263
730
798
281
798
798
281
375
513
1097 - 355 =T
933 - 115 =I
754 - 394 =H
577 - 64 =S
574 - 199 =R
790 - 52 =N
1196 - 398 =P
580 - 46 =O
601 - 320 =E
647 - 384 =C
566 - 370 =D
225 - 59 =F
1039 - 309 =Y
517 - 109 =A
0/14 letters found
Clue 2

Addition

Let us tally up the delivery tips left on the kitchen counter! Adding up all these dollar bills gives us a clue about the thief's delivery style.

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
603
596
562
656
782
800
817
226
T
603
895
552
562
447
226
656
447
552
782
T
603
T
603
562
817
447
782
T
603
596
T
603
596
562
435
562
423
T
603
596
226
817
253
319 + 284 =T
78 + 148 =A
367 + 195 =E
173 + 262 =L
260 + 187 =W
128 + 295 =F
273 + 509 =I
308 + 348 =S
155 + 98 =D
302 + 250 =R
458 + 437 =U
261 + 335 =H
534 + 266 =G
478 + 339 =N
0/14 letters found
Clue 3

Multiplication facts (1-12)

The delivery scooters are parked in neat equal rows in the garage. Multiply the rows of scooters by the number in each row to uncover a clue about their cap!

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

T
22
54
14
77
5
45
45
72
5
121
49
48
14
8
77
14
6
T
22
21
72
77
21
5
6
6
14
14
132
132
21
T
22
54
21
45
14
49
2 × 11 =T
7 × 11 =V
8 × 1 =R
1 × 5 =I
7 × 7 =S
7 × 2 =E
11 × 12 =P
11 × 11 =N
7 × 3 =O
9 × 5 =L
2 × 3 =D
9 × 6 =H
12 × 4 =W
9 × 8 =A
0/14 letters found
Clue 4

Rounding

The delivery tracking map is a bit blurry. We have to round the delivery distance to the nearest ten miles to find the route of the suspect!

Solve each problem to learn its letter. Then write that letter in every box that shows the same number, and read the secret clue.

C
700
8000
200
6000
90
30
400
60
200
4000
80
200
400
500
2000
4000
600
9000
200
9000
40
500
80
30
9000
3000
60
300
300
400
5000
40
800
Round 718 to the nearest hundredC
Round 8,613 to the nearest thousandE
Round 620 to the nearest hundredW
Round 829 to the nearest hundredX
Round 241 to the nearest hundredR
Round 40 to the nearest tenO
Round 458 to the nearest hundredN
Round 432 to the nearest hundredA
Round 28 to the nearest tenH
Round 8,441 to the nearest thousandU
Round 91 to the nearest tenY
Round 2,257 to the nearest thousandD
Round 5,429 to the nearest thousandB
Round 57 to the nearest tenI
Round 331 to the nearest hundredZ
Round 3,163 to the nearest thousandP
Round 5,821 to the nearest thousandL
Round 3,820 to the nearest thousandS
Round 78 to the nearest tenT
0/19 letters found
Clue 5

Division facts (1-12) — the last clue

It is time to share the giant leftover pizza! We must divide the slices equally among our team to unlock the final secret clue.

First solve each problem. Then find each answer in the list below and cross that sentence out. One sentence will be left — that's exactly what the villain did!

Step 1 — solve these
70 ÷ 10 = ?
120 ÷ 12 = ?
36 ÷ 6 = ?
24 ÷ 12 = ?
120 ÷ 10 = ?
36 ÷ 4 = ?
30 ÷ 6 = ?
24 ÷ 6 = ?
8 ÷ 8 = ?
6 ÷ 2 = ?
99 ÷ 9 = ?
Step 2 — cross out the sentence with each answer
1.The villain zooms away on a turbo scooter, then hands out extra cheesy bread.
2.The villain drives a speedy delivery van, then tosses fresh garlic knots.
3.The villain zooms away on a turbo scooter, then accidentally drops spicy peppers.
4.The villain pedals fast on a rocket skateboard, then hands out extra cheesy bread.
5.The villain pedals fast on a rocket skateboard, then tosses fresh garlic knots.
6.The villain drives a speedy delivery van, then hands out extra cheesy bread.
7.The villain zooms away on a turbo scooter, then knocks over a fizzy soda.
8.The villain races in a sleek go-kart, then hands out extra cheesy bread.
9.The villain races in a sleek go-kart, then tosses fresh garlic knots.
10.The villain pedals fast on a rocket skateboard, then leaves behind sweet cinnamon sticks.
11.The villain drives a speedy delivery van, then leaves behind sweet cinnamon sticks.
12.The villain zooms away on a turbo scooter, then tosses fresh garlic knots.
Solve it

Name the culprit

Choose the one suspect left standing.

About this mystery

Grade level
Grade 3 math
Math topics
Subtraction, Addition, Multiplication, Rounding, Division
Reading level
grades 3-4
Theme
The Case of the Golden Anchovy — set in Cheesy Valley Pizza District
Format
Interactive online & printable worksheet with answer key
Solution
One unique, verified culprit among 21 suspects

More free printable math mysteries

3rd grade worksheetsAddition worksheetsSubtraction worksheetsMultiplication worksheetsDivision worksheetsRounding worksheetsAll worksheets →
The Great Anchovy Heist
Grade 3
The Great Balloon Mystery
Grade 3
The Balloon Fiesta Mystery
Grade 3
The Sandy Flats Sandbox Mystery
Grade 3